The Appalachian | Archives | 2000-2001

This Issue: News | Sports | Opinion | Entertainment
The Appalachian - 262-6233
Boone, NC 28608
Sept. 14, 2000

Back to Current Issue

 
 
 
 
 

 

 

 

Sports

Knight is not solely responsible for decline of collegiate athletics

ASU rugby squad steamrolls UNC Greensboro 63-3

Kevin Burnette - Contributing Writer

With a devastating, 63-3 win over UNC-Greensboro, ASU Men's Rugby flexed its revamped muscles on Saturday at State Farm Intramural Fields.

Scorekeepers needed a calculator, as ASU charged down the field to score nine tries. Several successful conversion and penalty kicks added to the rout.

In the first half, ASU dominated Greensboro by utilizing superior rucking and mauling skills in forward play, and timely passing and support among the backs. These are the fundamentals of rugby and ASU executed them with discipline and skill.

Game day MVP flyhalf Patrick Mannion scored two tries in the first half. The first resulted from a series of ground gaining rucks by the scrum forwards. These put ASU within a few meters of the try-zone, then Mannion joined the attack and drove through the visitors defense for the try.

Near the end of the half, Mannion spun out of a tackle and wove through ten meters of defenders for his second try of the day. Strong side flanker William Elder contributed to the first half scoring barrage when he picked up the ball from a scrum, crashed into defenders after a 20-meter advance, then passed to supporting weakside flanker and Rugby Club President Jason Kovalcin for the try.

Then, on a penalty play near the goal line, Elder scored a try when he was well positioned in support to receive a pass from winger Robbie Blythe. In other first half scoring, former scrum veteran and new inside center Jason Pass tallied a try that originated from a maul set up by loose head prop Clay Elkins.

The second half had its own ASU heroes. Sophomore Nathan Bonifich smashed and drove through Greensboro not once, but twice for his first and second career tries.

Meanwhile wing Kevin Stogner skimmed along the sidelines, then bee-lined for the try zone with a pass from outside-center Eric Gebicke for his own career scoring initiation.

Toward the end of the match, Greensboro managed to get on the scoreboard with a penalty kick for three points.

Sideline spectator and alumni Mike Lauff said of ASU's performance, "It was good rugby all the way around."

The victory over UNC-Greensboro not only marked the beginning of a new season for ASU but also the debut of new head coach David Rogers.

Field captain and prop Tim Driscoll listed Rogers' rigorous practices and organizational leadership as one of the top factors in Saturday's win.

Coach Rogers was pleased with ASU's performance and remarked on the props' dominance within the scrums over Greensboro.

He also said that "the team implemented a good measure of the strategies and tactics we introduced in practice the past two weeks. We’re getting there."

"But toward the end of the second half our guys seemed to run out of gas. So fitness is an issue. That is something we have to work on before next week's game," Rogers said.

The return of Clay Elkins to ASU Rugby after almost a year on the injured list was a special match highlight. Last October, Elkins was involved in a severe traffic accident, shattering his leg, and has spent the past several months recuperating.

On his part in the Greensboro match, Elkins remarked, "I felt about 75 percent, but it was good to be back."

Led by flyhalf Scott Warren, scrumhalf Greg Schwartz, and No. 8 Brian Kandefer, ASU's B-side also won vs. Greensboro in convincing fashion, with a 29-3 win over the visitors.

Next Saturday, ASU Men's Rugby will see action in Charlotte against UNCC Rugby. This traditional grudge match promises to be one of the most challenging for ASU Men’s Rugby.

This match is made even more interesting when ASU’s William Elder faces off against twin brother Brian Elder playing for UNCC, with both at the flanker position in the scrum.


 

 

 

Golden balloons not enough to produce ASU win

Duke shuts out Mountaineer field hockey team 8-0

Ty Brueilly - Sports Minor Beat

Golden balloons were tied to the Appalachian State field hockey bench Tuesday night with various inspirational statements taped on all of them.

One balloon said, "Standout....make ASU stand out in the minds of others, leave an impression, make a splash."

The field hockey team has done that so far this season despite their 1-6 record. Even though they lost to an extremely talented and experinced Duke University team Tuesday night with the final score being 8-0, the comments afterwards by fans, parents and Duke coaches were nothing but good.

Duke coach Liz Tchou said, "You (the team) are real good this year, you're getting it done, much more oraginized, keep it up."

Appalachian coach Patience Harrison followed Tchous statement by saying "It's really amazing to me that every coach, every parent, every faculty member that has been a supporter during the years has said that the team is playing and is so much better, even their coach (Tchou) said that we look good, better than last year, I cant even say how many people tonight have said that, its amazing."

Appalachian had ninteen corner penalties in the game which allowed Duke for a great position on scoring. And Duke took adavntage of them. Duke actually only scored directly on two of them but were able to get the rebound from others to slap them into the goal.

Freshman Jesse Umstead said, "Our penalties held against us caused a great deal of scoring situations that they took advantage of, offensively we should have drawn some penalties so that we could put ourselves into their type positions."

On the other hand Duke only had one corner penalty which Appalachian did not take full advantage of. Appalachian had a hard time with the transition game which also played a factor in their loss. Meridth White said "If anything what hurt us was our tranition from defense to mid-field to offense."

Another factor that played in their loss was Duke's excellent mid field which enabled Duke to get the ball into the cirlce and either score or get another penalty corner called on Appalachian. White said "they are a really good team thier mid field especially."

Harrison is not about to let this loss bring the team down. What's going to be the hardest thing for the ladies is as Harrison said,

"It's tough on them and their confendence, their challenge is to recognize in fact that we have improved and not let the mental gain get out of them, not get swept away by a game, let it motivate them to push harder and be stronger."

After their loss the team, with their heads held high showed remarkable sportsmanship. The entire team and coaching staff huddled and emotionally and loudly said, "Good game Duke, thank you officials, thank you fans, way to play App." Showing exactly what that golden balloon said, "Standout...make ASU standout in the minds of others, leave an impression make a splash."


COMMENTARY

Knight is not solely responsible for decline of collegiate athletics

The firing of Coach Bob Knight of Indiana University came as no surprise, but there is more to this issue than a hot-headed coach out of a job or a shaken-up powerhouse basketball program.

Seems to me everyone is either on one side or the other.

On the one side, the feeling is that Bob Knight is a violent, foul-mouthed monster who deserved to be axed sooner than this. Looking at it from the other side, it seems that there is strong support for Bob Knight, an icon for Indiana basketball, and a legendary coach.

To say Bob Knight was a jerk--I'd say that would be accurate. To say Bob Knight's a horrible person, well that's another thing entirely.

Bob Knight coached basketball with a distinctive style that certainly by today's standards is perhaps too intense.

This style comes from the days when players had upmost respect and fear for their coaches--a relationship that has changed a lot since those days.

Basketball coaches today face players that have little respect for their mentors and much disregard for the now-ancient team-oriented player attitude.

Maybe Bob Knight's disciplinarian style is good for selfish players because he demands respect and he puts the team first.

I don't agree with Bob Knight throwing chairs or shouting profanities, but can't some value be attributed to Knight?

For one thing, Bob Knight has a 98% graduation rate.

What does this indicate? That Knight did put a major emphasis on getting an education.

Another way to get a sense of Bob Knight's influence is to examine player reactions to his firing.

Former player and NBA coach Isaiah Thomas said he would hire Knight onto the staff of the NBA's Indiana Pacers.

Now what does this say about Bob Knight and his value to young basketball players?

Several members of this year's Indiana Hoosiers had interesting takes on the situation.

Junior guard Dana Fife has declared he will transfer from Indiana because of Knight's dismissal, and freshman A.J. Moye feels that the entire school has been damaged by this incident.

You may wonder why any player would want to subject himself to Knight's ferocious coaching style, but there are plenty that do and prosper from it.

Another attribute of Knight's program is his clean record on NCAA violations or sanctions. This is a rarity, highlighted especially by the recent developments in the Minnesota basketball scandal.

For those of you not familiar with this story, NCAA investigations in 1999 uncovered evidence of 400 research papers and tests written by a tutor and given to 20 players during former head coach Clem Haskins tenure.

Haskins later admitted to paying the tutor $3000 and is currently being sued by the university to recover the $2.2 million buyout the university gave him when he resigned.

How is cursing and throwing chairs any worse than allowing players to cheat 400 times? I think Haskins and other coaches that encourage dishonesty are far more detrimental to young basketball players than Bob Knight.

Certainly I'm not condoning Bob Knight's behavior, especially in the areas of physical confrontations, but I don't think this story is as cut and dry as it appears.

Bob Knight broke the rules and he was fired. I just think it's a shame that he's been made into a target for everything that's wrong with college basketball. To dismiss Bob Knight as a cancer to college basketball is taking a shallow view of a sad, complex situation in college athletics.


 

 

 

 

Return to The Appalachian